The Worst “Christians” in the World

A couple of years ago the BBC aired a television documentary about Fred Phelps and Westboro Baptist (the “God Hates Fags” church). The documentary, The Most Hated Family in America, follows the BBC’s Louis Thoreaux as he spends time in Topeka with the Phelps. I watched it for the first time yesterday, and experienced the most anger and disgust I’ve ever felt towards people who supposedly worship the same God of the same religion and Bible as I do. I was thinking that if these people are Christians and are going to be in heaven one day, I don’t know if I want to be there with them. It’s a HIGHLY disturbing and maddening film for anyone to watch, but perhaps especially frightful for anyone who cares about Christianity and hates to see it be expressed in such a thoroughly skewed, unbiblical, self-serving manner.

Watch the whole thing (60 minutes long) here:

Some of the questions I asked myself after watching this: Why does God allow such crazy, fringe, ungodly people to be such a public face of the Christian church? Are these people actually Christians and is God using them in some purpose I don’t understand? If so, how can I blame anyone for not wanting to believe in this God? Is there any way we can shut down this church and silence the “God hates fags!” voice in a loving, nonviolent way? Why do the 30 people at Westboro Baptist get to do so much damage to the worldwide image of Christianity? What can the other billion of us Christians in the world do to counteract this?

I’ve been critical in recent years of the trend of Christians saying things like “I love Jesus but hate Christians” or “Lord, save us from your followers,” or similar variations on this “Christians are annoying but Jesus is cool” idea. But when there are people like the Phelps clan in Topeka who are masquerading as Christians and dragging that name in the filthiest kind of mud, I can’t help but understand why so many within the church are frantically trying to distance themselves from the designation.

Still, I think it’s wrong to get too worked up and worried by these sorts of people. That the Phelps—such a tiny anomaly of Christianity—could stir such a frustrated, stressed-out reaction in me ultimately indicates that I need to have a stronger faith. Not faith that I’m right and they’re wrong, but that God—above all earthly things—has a purpose and it will prevail, regardless of whatever stupid things people say or do in his name.

Christians today need to have confidence not in their own cultural dogmas or prophetic/martyrdom complexes (as in the Phelps’ insistence that God only smiles upon them and hates everyone else)—but rather confidence in Christ and his transforming, world-altering gospel. Contrary to what the Phelps might think, the Christian gospel is a hopeful message for the world and is about love rather than hate and grace rather than legalistic obsessing about the keeping of Mosaic laws.

Sure, there are unrepentant sinners. And yes, there is the wrath of God. But it’s God who will exact that wrath and doll out judgment as he sees fit. As Christians we should focus on thanking God, worshipping him and being imitators of Christ—which means loving and serving the world unconditionally and spreading a message of resurrection hope.

I don’t know what Bible Phelps reads or what God Westboro Baptist worships, but I’m not going to worry too much about it. They can call themselves Christians (even though they aren’t living Christianly) all they want; It won’t change the truth of who Christ actually was and what he actually said and did.

13 responses to “The Worst “Christians” in the World

  1. “I was thinking that if these people are Christians and are going to be in heaven one day, I don’t know if I want to be there with them.”

    Do you believe it?

  2. No I don’t, but the Phelps cult is sure adamant that they in fact will be in heaven and pretty much everyone else won’t be.

  3. I went to Cornerstone music festival a few years ago and got to talking with some of the religious protesters outside the event. While they weren’t quite as bad as Phelps and his crew, I quickly realized that there was nothing I could say that would change their mind.

    And that’s what bothers me the most about Phelps and every other “Christian” like him. They are so fixed on their one-track mission that they are completely blind to any outside force. It’s really frustrating and disheartening, then, because there is little chance of getting them to stop.

  4. I have a feeling that when Fred is at the pearly gates, St. Peter will like that old David Spade skit. “Right, and you are . . . ?”

  5. ‘Why does God allow such crazy, fringe, ungodly people to be such a public face of the Christian church?”

    I think the answer is the same as the question of why God allows Brittany Spears to be the public face of pop singers–he doesn’t allow those things specifically, but he does allow the sin of media-frenzy-over-crazy-people.

    It ain’t right, but it’s par for the course.

  6. I was just having a heated argument last Sunday with a guy I grew up with and knew for over ten years. We go to the same church and listen to the same sermons, yet he claimed that he hated all gays and that if it wasn’t against the law, that he might even kill some of them. It’s times like this when I wonder if I’m reading the same Bible as my fellow Christians.

    As for “What can the other billion of us Christians in the world do to counteract this?,” I think you’re doing your own part in your way. I’m seventeen years old and your blog is one of the sources that molds my own faith. All I can think to do is to keep talking about this issue to other Christians and to do my own part by showing love and respect to any and everyone.

  7. It was actually somewhat of a relief to watch this because it exposed how warped their thinking is. I only wish they had been asked more probing questions about the basis of their faith. I feel that they’re a good example of someone who keeps the letter of the law, but neglects the spirit.
    I also found it really creepy that they never swore, using phrases like “goodness gracious” or “poopy” yet they said it with such obvious disdain and contempt it rang out as more harsh then the dirtiest of curse words. I don’t swear either, but I don’t tell people “you’re just being silly” in a way that completely disregards their thoughts.

  8. This makes me think of the Derek Webb song “Freddie, Please” addressed to Phelps.

    May God have mercy on us all.

  9. What if they are right and we are wrong?

  10. What if they are right and we are wrong?

    Then the Bible is worthless, and God is not a god worth knowing.

  11. I suspect that, if they remain on this path, they will get the “heaven” that they really desire… a la C.S. Lewis’. We all get what we actually desire, whether we realize what our actual desires are or not.

  12. well i guess if you have john piper in your blog roll, you have to believe these guys were ordained to do what they do from b4 the foundation of the world. they are god ordained as you believe all things are, so they must be ok.

  13. “Tashlan”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s