Stasis and Catharsis in Ten Contemporary Films

tree_1.jpg

In Paul Schrader’s 1972 book, Transcendental Style in Film, the renowned filmmaker/theorist (with a Christian background… he went to Calvin) outlined his theory for how transcendence is achieved stylistically in cinema. The ultimate embodiment of the transcendent, he thinks, is in something called stasis: “a frozen view of life which does not resolve the disparity but transcends it.” Stasis often occurs at the end of a film, and often in the final shot—when the conflict or “disparity” is not completely resolved, but “frozen” into stasis. “To the transcending mind,” Schrader writes, “man and nature may be perpetually locked in conflict, but they are paradoxically one and the same.”

This “Oneness” is a sort of resolution of the unresolved—an arrival at peace in spite of and because of a deep unsettledness within the soul. I think the concept has echoes of G.K. Chesterton’s notion of “divine discontent”—the idea that we should feel ill at ease with our human situation, and as such more aware of the divine other that will one day right every wrong. Discontent can be divine—and transcendent—when we view it as a sign of the perfect Source (God), apart from which all else is unresolved tension.

Thus, Schrader keenly points out (and I agree), that films exposing glimpses of the transcendent are often those that end on a note that is at once satisfying (catharsis) and whole (stasis), but also still in want. “The static view,” Schrader writes, represents a world “in which the spiritual and physical can coexist, still in tension and unresolved, but as part of a larger scheme in which all phenomena are more or less expressive of a larger reality—the Transcendent.”

Some examples Schrader uses to flesh out this idea include the final, lengthy shot of the vase at the end of Ozu’s Late Spring (1949), or the shadow of the cross that becomes the final shot of Diary of a Country Priest (1950).

I’ve been thinking about current films (films of the last six or seven years) that Schrader might point to as pictures that exemplify stasis—that encapsulate a oneness or transcendence that leaves the viewer wholly affected and frozen in time. These are the films that, upon fading or cutting to black, leave you utterly breathless and emotionally (perhaps spiritually) wrecked. I’m not talking about tearjerkers or films that have shocking trick endings where everything changes in the final shot (don’t get me wrong, I love M. Night Shyamalan). I’m talking about films that leave you both devastated and satisfied, with a final image that is burned into your mind’s eye. Here are a few that are still burning in my mind (warning: spoiler city!):

A.I. (2001): The ending of this film was widely criticized by many for being both too drawn out and too sappy. But for me, it was the perfect, haunting ending to a film that remains remarkably affecting each time I watch it. It is devastating to witness Haley Joel Osment’s sentient little robot boy being forced to live for thousands of years without the human love from which he has come to derive his meaning. In the last scene, he gets to live one last day with his reincarnated mother, before they both cease to exist forever. I’m not sure what it is about this ending (perhaps the immense weight of time, mortality, and existence, which we are forced to consider), but as the camera pans back from the two going to “sleep,” something aches in the pit of my stomach.

b2_sunset_3img_assist_custom.jpg

Before Sunset (2004): Not all evocative, stasis endings have to be downers. In Richard Linklater’s marvelous Before Sunset (the sequel to 1995’s Before Sunrise), the ending—while certainly not providing “Hollywood” closure—offers a breezy, life-affirming catharsis that is both ambiguous and perfectly settled. As Ethan Hawke sits on a couch in Julie Delpy’s Paris apartment, we watch as she playfully mimics a flirty Nina Simone. Then the scene just joyfully fades to black. I can’t recall a film that left me so wholly satisfied, despite not knowing exactly how the story ended up.

Capote (2005): Sometimes the stasis of a film is reinforced by some postscript that comes onscreen after the film’s final image. In Capote, an already wrenching final image (of Philip Seymour Hoffman in a plane, looking forlornly out a window) is enhanced by the words that follow as the screen goes black: “In Cold Blood made Truman Capote the most famous writer in America. He never finished another book. The epigraph he chose for his last, unfinished work reads: ‘More tears are shed over answered prayers than unanswered ones.’”

Children of Men (2006): In the case of Children of Men, the most affecting stasis comes from the aural denouement—the voices and sounds of children playing which bookend the film. As Kee and Theo drift out to sea, quietly and away from the chaos of the previous two hours, all appears lost. Theo is bleeding, and soon succumbs. Kee is alone with her newborn baby. Suddenly the rescue boat (“The Tomorrow”) appears, and our hopes are renewed. But instead of providing a full resolution, the images stop there. “CHILDREN OF MEN” flashes against a black screen, with the children’s laughter heard faintly in the background. It’s ambiguous. It’s disturbing. It’s uneasy peace.

L’Enfant (2006): Many of the films by Belgian directors the Dardenne Brothers contain endings in which some sort of cathartic resolution is achieved, but quickly halted (as in, the screen goes black in the middle of some intense, penultimate scene). This is the case in L’Enfant, a film about a man (Jeremy Renier) who does unspeakable things in order to make financial ends meet. The power of this film’s ending is in its juxtaposition to the emotional distance of everything preceding it. Not until the final few minutes does Renier—having been completely broken down—show any emotion at all. This scene provides a stunning catharsis, but very little resolution. And as the screen abruptly goes black, the unifying power of that final image is left for the awestruck viewer to mull over.

lostintranslation.png

Lost In Translation (2003): Sofia Coppola really leaves us hanging at the end of this film. The two main characters (Scarlett Johansson and Bill Murray) share an intimate few whispers as they say farewell, and we don’t have a clue what they say to each other! Oddly, though, this unanswered question gives the film’s somber ending a wonderful sense of uncertain hope. Maybe they’ll meet again, maybe not. One never knows with these sorts of evanescenent encounters. As the Jesus and Mary Chain song (“Just Like Honey”) plays over a montage of the empty streets of Tokyo at dawn, and the characters go their separate ways, a morning-after mix of bittersweet joy and existential ache abides. Another day. Life goes on.

The New World (2005): “Life goes on” is a good way to look at the theme of this amazing film from director Terrence Malick. In the film, Pocahontas (Q’Orianka Kilcher) is put through the ringer, being relentlessly battered by love, change, regret, and ultimately death. Through it all, though, Malick reminds us of new life—of nature, and trees which grow always ever upwards, even when branches fall off. The final shot of the film, then, is a profound encapsulation of this theme. After a stunning closing montage (to the music of Wagner’s swelling Das Rheingold), the final shot looks upwards at a tree, stately and shining in the sunlight. The music stops, a single leaf falls to the ground, and the screen goes to black. Amazingly, the credits roll over silence (initially), which amplifies the meditation over stasis even more.

Nine Lives (2005): This little-seen, remarkably conceived film is really a collection of nine short films—each shot in solitary, 12 minute camera takes, and each with its own stasis ending. Each story is a snippet of one woman’s life, and as such we know neither where they’ve come from nor where they’re going. Because of top-notch writing, directing and acting, however, we invest in these characters enough to be jarred when their segment flashes to black and the next one begins. A couple of the episodes end on especially moving notes (the episode with Robin Wright Penn in a supermarket, for example), but the final one with Glenn Close and Dakota Fanning takes the stasis cake.

The Pianist (2002): The ending of this film is pure catharsis. After two and a half hours of death and horror, our protagonist (Adrian Brody) is finally redeemed, and over the end titles, he performs Chopin’s magnificent Grande Polonaise for piano & orchestra with the Warsaw Philharmonic in a concert hall. Like the beautiful music played throughout the film, it is both sad and triumphant—equal parts emotional release and spiritual requiem for lost beauty and innocence. Very few films’ end titles are so riveting that not a single audience member leaves for five+ minutes. But this was the case when I saw The Pianist.

united-93.jpg

United 93 (2006): This was the best film of 2006 for a number of reasons, not least of which is its incredibly intense climax and subsequent catharsis ending. After 100 minutes of heart-pumping, visceral filmmaking (the soundtrack is literally rhythmic heart-pumping) we are brought to final ten minutes—a stretch which affected me physically (as in, sweaty palms, rapid heartbeat) more than any film I can remember. Then, when the plane finally crashes and the music reaches its haunting home chord, the chaos is silenced and a numb sense of shock and lamentation takes over. I found it hard to move in my chair during the credits.

These are just ten examples that I thought of off the top of my head, but doubtless there are many more. What films do you think of when you think about powerful stasis or catharsis endings?

Advertisements

10 responses to “Stasis and Catharsis in Ten Contemporary Films

  1. What about “Punch Drunk Love” (“So here we go…”)? And also under similar circumstances (sort of): “Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind” (“okay..”). And if i recall correctly, doesn’t “Little Children” end with a fairly profound moment of stasis? I also was reminded of “Taxi Driver” which obviously isn’t recent. There almost seems to be two moments of stasis in that film. I also thought about “Half Nelson” but I think that may be true to a much lesser extent. It is pretty much inferred that Dan Dunne is going to clean up, but we don’t know for sure that he will follow through. He seems to want to, their seems to have been a turning point in his life, but things remain fairly unclear all the same.

    It seems that the most powerful moments of stasis are surrounded by a sense of hope, or the idea of hope. For the viewer anyway. We don;t know for sure that Dan Dunne will be okay but we hope so. We hope that he hopes so too. Anyway…just a few thoughts. Might be way off base…interesting post.

  2. Great, great choices. With the exception of Nine Lives (which I haven’t seen), I can still vividly recall the endings for each of the films listed here. (I especially agree with your appraisal of A.I., which remains a misunderstood masterpiece.)

    The only film after A.I. which achieved “stasis” for me was Polanski’s Oliver Twist. The orphaned boy’s visit to Fagin’s prison cell, followed by the image of the hangman’s gallows being erected, all the way through the closing credits, were the most emotionally shattering in Polanski’s career, and conceivably the highest point in my moviegoing experience. Yes, I think I could write an entire paper on that final scene.

    Reaching back a few years, the ending to Shadow of the Vampire, in which Dafoe’s Nosferatu is burned to light, is both a transcendental moment and a profound comment on the nature of the medium.

    I think the silent comedians understood how to capture transcendent moments as well as anyone. Take any of Keaton’s or Chaplin’s endings for example.

  3. There are two movies after which, credits rolling, I’ve just truly wept– both of which, interestingly enough, you includ here. Lost in Translation and United 93.

    Contra Punch-Drunk Love, after which I couldn’t stop smiling.

    Not sure I fully understand the stasis/catharsis distinction w/r/t films, but I know what they do to me.

    (Glad to see the A.I. love.)

  4. Matthew-
    Yeah I wept after seeing Lost in Translation too… I saw it alone as part two of a double feature (the first was “Thirteen”… it was not a happy day at the movies). And United 93 just left me so flabbergasted I could hardly move, let alone speak.
    And yeah, A.I. deserves more love.

  5. Pingback: MH Arts | A Recommendation

  6. Good, thoughtful article. Thanks for that.

    In terms of movies I liked:
    Open Your Eyes (Abre los ojos) and the remake, Vanilla Sky, certainly leave much open to interpretation. The director’s cut of Blade Runner is a classic example. Charlie Kaufmann seems to like wide-open endings (Adaptation, Being John Malkovich, and the aforementioned Eternal Sunshine). The Usual Suspects is a masterpiece, including the ending.

    What about Donnie Darko?

  7. Brett:

    I have just been looking at your website after being directed here by a friend. And strangely (or not) over the weekend I have been reading a book of Flannery O’Connor’s essays, “Mystery and Manners.” I suspect you are familiar with it but if not, an important theme of these collected talks is that a Christian artist (in this case, a writer) often shocks his Christian audience (in this case, readers) with works that really show redemption. And that is because many, if not most, people — Christian or not — are relativists and don’t believe there is anything to be redeemed from. So as you have said in several of these posts, an R rated movie or songs that are not of the happy-feelgood-rah-rah God! variety can convince people of grace and their need for it. She mentions several times the emptiness of works made to show religious points but that are not realistic, and I think this is what plagues so many well-meaning bands and films and books in the “Christian” market. They are not convincing, they just gloss over reality.

    United 93 nearly gave me a heart attack. I don’t believe that my husband or I moved from the moment it started to the moment it ended.

    How about the end of the Coen Brothers’ version of “The Ladykillers,” when the barge drifts silently off the the garbage island/Hell and Tom Hanks’s torn coat flaps up to the sky? I am fond of that one.

  8. And Terrence Malick’s The Thin Red Line.

  9. Claire Paradine

    Le Humanite by Bruno Dumont

  10. Definitely consider that which you said.
    Your favorite reason seemed to be at the internet the easiest thing
    to keep in mind of. I say to you, I certainly get irked even as people consider concerns that they plainly do not recognise about.

    You managed to hit the nail upon the highest and also defined out the
    whole thing with no need side-effects , other
    folks can take a signal. Will likely be back to get more.
    Thanks

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s