Top Ten Most Unflattering Portrayals of Christians in Film

Because top ten lists are fun, and because I’ve been thinking a lot recently about how Christians are perceived in culture, I thought it would be interesting to comprise a list of the most unflattering portrayals of Christians in cinema. On a future post I will probably do the same for the most flattering portrayals.

Keep in mind that I am not slamming these films; several of them are actually very well made. I’m only pointing out that, for secular audiences watching these films, Christians come across as crazy, annoying, dangerous, stupid, or some combination therein. Thankfully most of these films were not seen by very many people. But even so, I think it’s important to be mindful that they exist—that for some people, this is the only picture of Christianity they have.

51zm1nsnknl_ss500_.jpg10) Why Should the Devil Have all the Good Music? (2004)
Though less hostile than most documentaries about Christians, this incoherent exploration of a much-too-broad topic leaves the viewer as confused and cynical as the disparate talking heads that sound off in the film.

71q4wy4rxwl_aa240_.jpg9) Night of the Hunter (1955)
This classic kicked off the “fundamentalist Christian as psychopath” trend that has been a favorite in cinema ever since. “Leaning On the Everlasting Arms” has never sounded as disturbing as when Robert Mitchum sings it.

51dc5nhyssl_aa240_.jpg8) My Summer of Love (2004)
More tragic than comical, this indie film portrays a group of British evangelicals as positively bonkers and dangerous to family dynamics, as one of the church’s leaders (Paddy Considine) pays more attention to prayer meetings than he does his own struggling family.

519yjscqqyl_aa240_.jpg7) The Virgin Suicides (1999)
Repressive Christian parents (James Woods and Kathleen Turner) in suburbia drive their innocent daughters to suicide. Because not being able to go to prom just does that to you…

41vya0s7ksl_aa240_.jpg6) Citizen Ruth (1996)
It’s pretty gutsy to satirize abortion, but Alexander Payne did it successfully in this film, which lampoons both the firebrand evangelical pro-lifers and the equally insane pro-choice feminazis.

41f8bashpl_aa240_.jpg5) Facing the Giants (2006)
Oops! I thought this was made by Christians!? Indeed, but this horrendous film (which we have Georgia’s Sherwood Baptist Church to thank for) is as embarrassing to Christians as anything Pat Robertson ever said.

5193nba10cl_aa240_.jpg4) Saved! (2004)
This film relentlessly points out evangelical absurdities, featuring a command performance from Mandy Moore as the Christian school queen bee who spreads Jesus’ love by throwing bibles at people.

51rkjjzs12l_aa240_.jpg3) Jonestown: The Life and Death of People’s Temple (2006)
To the uninitiated, People’s Temple appears to be just one more crazy sect of fundamentalist Christianity. Which makes this true story of delusion and mass suicide one of the most damaging witnesses to American Christianity in the twentieth century.

31rnwfmchml_aa240_.jpg2) Hell House (2001)
A truly scary documentary about a Pentecostal church in Texas that uses Halloween, buckets of fake blood, and scenes of abortion, suicide, and AIDS to scare hordes of lost kids into accepting Jesus.

510jrnqd6dl_aa240_.jpg1) Jesus Camp (2006)
In addition to its portrayal of six year olds speaking in tongues and praying over a cardboard George W. Bush, this film boasts the honor of having grade-A ironic footage of Ted Haggard talking smack about gays just months before his own admission of having solicited a male prostitute.

5 responses to “Top Ten Most Unflattering Portrayals of Christians in Film

  1. I think people love to hate christians. But I think the majority of the time it’s for the wrong reasons. There’s hating christianity because you’re afraid of confronting the truth. But there’s also hating christianity because you’re seeing tons of phonies out there using religion to feel some sort of self-validation or to nurse their insecurities. That’s the repulsive, absurd, and often comical image that the secular masses see most of, which, in turn, makes the rest of us look bad (or really good, depending on how you look at it.)

  2. Number 9 is an interesting choice because it also provides one of the most flattering portrayals of a Christian in film (Lillian Gish, with a shotgun across her lap).

  3. honestly, i tend to avoid movies such as these for those very reasons. the list of movies that bash chrisitianity seems to grow (i.e. brokeback, chuck and larry) – then again the Bible says the world doesn’t understand and because of it they will reject.

  4. Pingback: Collide Magazine » Blog Archive » Links of the Week

  5. Brett, This is an interesting list. I’ve only seen a few of the movies on here–Thanks be to God. However, my critique of the list is there really isn’t a fair set of guidelines for judging what makes the list unflattering, i.e., certain movies on this list in no way compare to the others. Saved, is made to point out the foolishness of Fundamentalists and the shame/graceless-ness of Fundamentals as where Hell House and Jesus People just point out the absurdity that is particular movements within the Christian faith. You should write an article about Fred Phelps and his church in Topeka, KS–a movie about this church would be right up there with Jesus People.

    I can’t quite put my finger on it yet, but there is something about the list seems disconnected because a couple of the movies are made to depict the difference between grace /acceptance compared to power disguised in scarcity while others just point out the absurdity of some Christians.

    Just a few of my thoughts, take ’em or leave ’em. Other than that, I love the side bar of quotes and images. I’d love to see some Barth and Hauerwass up there too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s