CCM Albums of the 90s That Make Christian Hipsters Nostalgic

A lot of Christian hipsters today were raised in the evangelical Christian subculture in the 90s. Thus, while most of them have completely abandoned CCM by now, they still look fondly and nostalgically (with a smidge of irony) upon the Christian music they were reared on. Here are 20 albums that Christian hipsters today love to listen to for a trip down memory lane. What would you add to this list?

Amy Grant, Heart in Motion (1991)
Michael W. Smith, Change Your World (1993)
DC Talk, Free at Last (1993)
DC Talk, Jesus Freak (1995)
Audio Adrenaline, Bloom (1996)
Newsboys, Take Me To Your Leader (1996)
Rebecca St. James, God (1996)
Jars of Clay, Jars of Clay (1995)
Third Day, Conspiracy No. 5 (1997)
OC Supertones, Adventures of the OC Supertones (1997)
Reality Check, Reality Check (1997)
Plankeye, The One and Only (1997)
Project 86, Project 86 (1998)
Mxpx, Life in General (1998)
Sixpence None the Richer, Sixpence None the Richer (1998)
Plumb, candycoatedwaterdrops (1999)
Insyderz, Skalleluia (1999)
All Star United, International Anthems for the Human Race (1999)
POD, Fundamental Elements of Southtown (1999)
Switchfoot – New Way to be Human (1999)

About these ads

43 Responses to CCM Albums of the 90s That Make Christian Hipsters Nostalgic

  1. Any album by Five Iron Frenzy.

  2. Yeah, I was about to bring FIF up too. I don’t know anyone who even thinks about the Insyderz anymore; I know plenty of people who still listen to Five Iron Frenzy from time to time.

    Also, nobody’s nostalgic for Project 86′s self-titled album. Their second, Drawing Black Lines, is far superior, and that was the one that got the most radio play, as far as I can remember.

    The Waiting should also be on here, though I’m not surprised that they’re not. The most underrated, unjustly neglected band in all of CCM, in my opinion.

    • I’m with you on The Waiting. A few years back my wife bought me tickets to see The Waiting and Smalltown Poets but the concert was canceled.

  3. Ha! My first thought was also Five Iron Frenzy…amazing.

    Carman, anyone!? Addicted To Jesus!?

  4. Kids Praise 5. It’s the one when Psalty and the kids go camping.

  5. Thanks for the trip down memory lane! I have lots of these (some on vinyl!). Still listen to a couple of these artists: ASU, JoC, Switchfoot

  6. Old Bebo Norman or Caedmon’s Call. That CCM folk was big for me. Why hide it…anyone else?

  7. Skillet’s first self-titled album (“Saturn”, anyone?”)

    Major echo on Caedmon’s Call and Bebo, though both had the rare capacity to transcend the cheese. Jennifer Knapp’s Kansas is the same–though “Undo Me” made us think for a minute that CCM had found it’s inner Alanis Morrisette–but the album revealed much, much more.

    Great as “Take Me to Your Leader” was, “Going Public” was far superior.

    I would add Bleach’s album “Clean” to the list–they were the closest CCM thing to Smashing Pumpkins and put on a heck of a show.

    Also, I would echo “The Waiting”, both the self-titled disk of infectious, quirky wordplay tunes. They were to 90′s CCM what REM was to early alternative.

    Then there were the bands you wish held it together–(Burlap to Cashmere, even the randomness of Church of Rhythm, or Tony Vincent, who’s now a Broadway star)

    Hmm…that’s about it for now…although, everyone who grew up with CCM will always know Petra means rock…

  8. If you’re going to throw MWS on there, you might as well include Steven Curtis Chapman, “The Great Adventure,” featuring the dreadfully amazing “Got 2 B Tru,” where S C-squared listens to dcT and decides to rap. And then TobyMac himself comes on the scene to tell him he sucks.

    It would take cult-deprogramming people to erase these lyrics from my brain.

  9. FIF indeed!

  10. Wow, memories of youth group conventions & music festivals, early cassettes & cd’s and all of my first concerts just came to mind. Thank you. Excellent list.

    Still a fan of Five Iron. I would definitely add Jennifer Knapp to that list.

  11. Matthew Ables

    Definitely Caedmon’s Call, especially that first album.
    Add some Chris Rice, Nicole Nordeman, and a local band called Silar’s Bald.

  12. Haha – Is it sad that I’m proud of rejecting most of that music?
    I did like Five Iron Frenzy and the W’s. Twas the time for ska.
    Also:
    Dime Store Prophets – Love is Against the Grain
    Hokus Pick Maneuver – Pick it Up
    Black Eyed Sceva – 5 years…
    Some TOMfest stuff: Joy Electric, 5 O’clock People, and The Violent Burning!
    I still listen to Caedmon’s Call. :)

  13. How about Starflyer 59′s Silver and Gold albums?

  14. I agree with Caedmon’s Call’s first album, as well as some of Chris Rice’s album Past the Edges.

    And Brett, the first two albums you list are still two of my absolute favorite albums of all time. I found Heart in Motion at Cheapo’s in Minneapolis’ crazy-hip neighborhood Uptown and got ridiculously excited. And for two dollars! My then girlfriend was kind of embarrassed for me.

  15. Ha. Good to hear somebody else reference Hokus Pick. That was a hysterically great band by CCM standards ;)

    If you go back and listen to Audio A’s “Bloom”, it’s really a pretty solid album musically, and an ok album lyrically.

    And while the 1st Jars album was pretty awesome (was anybody else doing acoustic guitars and drum machines back then?), the 2nd Jars of Clay album will always have a place in my “Masterpiece Albums” list. It’s one step down, imho, from being described as “Beatles-level great”.

    Which is why, of course, it never went over ;)

    So here’s my question–was CCM back then just as ridiclous as it is now?

  16. Great list, Brett.

    I agree that FIF should be included, but would also include Goti Hook’s ridiculous album Banana Man. Loved that as a kid. Also agree with The Waiting being included.

  17. Poor Old Lu- Straight Six.
    I still listen to it and love it.

  18. I really liked FIF, Ghoti Hook (my first concert) and Starflyer 59.

    I also really loved The Hunger by Seven Day Jesus and The Moon Is Down by Further Seems Forever, both of which I still listen too.

    And what about Stavesacre? They were great back in the day. Plus pretty much any other Tooth & Nail band.

  19. 40 Acres? Hello?

  20. Funny thing is I have an iTunes playlist already created for when I want to get nostalgic

    A lot that you listed already, but also some of these:

    Seven Day Jesus “The Hunger”
    Stavesacre “Speakeasy”
    The Prayer Chain “Shawl”
    Grammatrain “Lonely House”
    Dryve “Thrify Mr. Kickstar”
    Common Children “Delicate Fade”
    The Choir “Free Flying Soul”
    Bloomsday “The Day the Colors Died”
    Black Eyed Sceva “5 Years, 50000 Miles Davis”
    Waterdeep “Sink or Swim”

    I may crank up the playlist again since you just reminded me of it.

  21. Sonicflood Self-titled

    Btw, shameless plug: Grant Norswothy, Sonicflood Bassist is speaking at my church, City Church in Anaheim this Sunday at 10:30am. Anyone is welcome, we meet at Chain Reaction near Lincoln and Euclid. Hipsters also welcome–and yes, I have no shame.

  22. how about the late 80′s… Petra – This means war, Whiteheart – Emergency Broadcast, and the “White metal” scene…Stryper, Whitecross, One Bad Pig, Barren Cross, Bloodgood, and Vengeance. 2 great artists I still listen to, the late Rich Mullins and Rez Band

  23. Pingback: TanForLess blog

  24. POD and Sixpence are the only ones I ever listen to. The others I hated when they came out. Ug. What a bad time.

  25. Children’s music:

    Amy Grant, Heart in Motion (1991)
    Michael W. Smith, Change Your World (1993)
    DC Talk, Free at Last (1993)
    DC Talk, Jesus Freak (1995)
    Audio Adrenaline, Bloom (1996)
    Newsboys, Take Me To Your Leader (1996)
    Rebecca St. James, God (1996)

  26. Note to everyone: this is awesome. Forgive the shilling, but my book on growing up with Christian rock in the 90s comes out in October, and pretty much every band and record mentioned here is in it.

    Kyle: Mercury > Shawl

  27. Pingback: The House Studio | Monday morning is for the random – Day Late Edition

  28. A few weeks ago, I took a listen to Jesus Freak for the first time in a long time. I was surprised by how well it held up. Personally speaking, it is the quintessential CCM record of the 90′s and although I abhor the rapping that Toby Mac does (it seriously gives me, what I call, Chills of Embarassment), these guys knew how to put together a record.

  29. Great list. I was also a big Smalltown Poets fan. I still love the music video for “There Is Only You,” with the cakewalk. Hilarious.

  30. Back in 1994, my youth pastor got his hands on the cd “Songs from the Loft” and we pretty much heard it nonstop at any youth functions at my church in Hendersonville, TN. Featured Amy Grant, Gary Chapman, Ashley Cleveland, Susan Ashton, etc.

  31. Definitely agree with Violet Burning and The Prayer Chain for proto-hipster nostalgia.

    Also, with anything from Tooth and Nail, but only from the early to mid 90s.

    Further back, I want to specify not just MSW, but especially the “Secret Ambition” music video – particularly when used at a “cool” youth group event to proceed an altar call.

  32. nick warkentien

    you hit that nail on the head!

  33. Note that my music includes some secular emo as well as a ton of christian rock. Anyway, here is my list of bands:
    Aleixa Altered Altered Mission The Appleseed Cast
    Armor For Sleep
    The Ataris Audio Adrenaline
    Ballydowse Believable Picnic Big Dog Small Fence Black Cherry Soda Black Eyed Sceva
    Blackball The Blamed
    Blaster The Rocket Boy Bleach Blenderhead
    Blindside
    Blindside Feat. Billy Corgan Blood-Shedd
    Bloomsday Bon Voyage Boy+Rocket Brandtson
    Brave Saint Saturn Brazil Bride Broomtree
    Buck Burlap To Cashmere Caedmon’s Call
    Calibretto 13 Chatterbox Chevelle The Choir Christafari
    Clash of Symbols
    Clash of Symbols Code Of Ethics Coheed & Cambria
    Common Children
    The Cootees Copeland Counterfit Craig’s Brother Crooked Smile Cross My Heart The Crossing The Crush Dakoda Motor Co.
    Damien Jurado Dashboard Confessional
    David Bazan dc Talk
    Dear Ephesus Delirious?
    The Dell Griffiths The Deluxtone Rockets
    Dime Store Prophets Dogwood
    Driver Eight Dryve EDL Element 101 Embodyment
    Emery
    Engage Ethereal Scourge Everdown
    Every Day Life
    Fanmail Finch Fine China
    Five Iron Frenzy
    Flight 180 Flyleaf Focal Point Focused Fold Zandura
    Further Seems Forever
    Galactic Cowboys The Get Up Kids
    Ghoti Hook
    Glisten The Gloria Record Goodnight Star Grammatrain
    Guardian Havalina Rail Co. Hawk Nelson Hey Mercedes The Hoi Polloi
    Hokus Pick
    Holy Soldier Homegrown Honey Hot Rod Circuit
    Hot Snakes
    House Of Wires The Huntingtons
    ‘Imisi Impact Insyderz
    The Israelites
    Jars Of Clay Jebediah Jeremiah’s Grotto Jeremy Enigk Jesse’s Vineyard Jets To Brazil
    Jimmy Eat World
    Joe Christmas Johnny Respect
    Joy Electric
    The Juliana Theory
    Kerith Ravine Kevin Clay KimThomas,Jim Thomas, Say-So Klank Kosmos Express The Kreepdowns Kutless Lament Lassie Foundation Leaderdogs For The Blind Lifesaver Living Sacrifice Loudflower Luxury Maintain Michael Knott Mind Set Mineral
    Model Engine Morella’s Forest Mortal
    Mukala
    MxPx
    Name Taken New End Original Newsboys
    Ninety Pound Wuss Niv No Innocent Victim
    No Motiv Not For The Crowd The O.C. Supertones
    One Eighty One:21
    Outer Circle Over The Rhine
    Overcome P.O.D.
    PAX217 Pedro The Lion
    Pete Stewart, Grammatrain
    PFR Plankeye
    Plumb Point Center Polarboy Poor Old Lu
    Pop Unknown
    The Prayer Chain The Prodigal Sons Project 86 The Promise Ring
    Puller
    Pushstart Wagon Rackets And Drapes The Rainy Days Raspberry Jam Rebecca St. James
    Relient K
    Resolve Rhubarb Rich Young Ruler
    Roadside Monument
    Rob Walker Roper Rose Blossom Punch Royal Ruby Joe
    Rufio Sal Paradise Sappo Sarah Masen Satellite Soul Saves The Day
    The Seeds Seldom Seven Day Jesus
    SHeeSh
    Sherri Youngward Sick Of Change Silage Sixpence None The Richer
    Skillet Skratchline Slick Shoes
    Smalltown Poets
    Smalltown Poets (Villanelle)
    So
    Soap Box Sometime Sunday
    Soulfood 76
    Spitfire Split Level Spoken
    Spooky Tuesday Spudpuddle Spy Glass Blue Squad Five-O
    Starflyer 59
    Stavesacre
    Steve Taylor Stretch Arm Strong Strongarm Student Rick Sunny Day Real Estate
    Switchfoot
    Taking Back Sunday Thee Spivies
    Third Day This Train
    Thousand Foot Krutch Threethirteen Thrice
    Throes Thursday
    Time Again Tragedy Ann Tripl3fastaction Triple Fast Action Underoath
    Up Hold Upside Down Room
    The Used Value Pac
    Various Artists
    Velocipedes Velour 100
    Viva Voce W’s The Waiting
    Watashi Wa Wyrick Yellowcard
    Yum Yum Children Zao 3rd Root 44 Evergiven 90LB.Wuss

  34. Josh–JOE CHRISTMAS!!! Coupleskate, one of my favorite music videos..man some of these bands were way ahead of their time! Sunny Day Real Estate, Pedro the Lion, Further Seems Forever, Ninety Pound Wuss, LIving Sacrifice, Zao (saw them!) Hung out w/ Dogwood and One 21 too, awesome guys! thanks for taking me down memory lane of my high school years!!! Holy Cow I miss all that music!!!!

  35. Grammatrain and Fold Zandura.

  36. Dakota Motor Club
    Small Town Poets
    The original Third Day album (on Gray Dot records before it was re-released).
    The Prayer Chain
    Mike Knott
    Christafari
    Gospel Gangstas
    Crux
    Guardian

    Used to watch Z-TV on satellite and read HM magazine. Good stuff.

  37. This is maybe because I’m a smidge on the young side of Christian hipsterdom, but I always go for Supertones Strike Back over Adventures. And why on earth is there no Rich Mullins on this list?

  38. No Deliriou5? Apparently you didn’t feel the mountains tremble …

  39. Pingback: They Don’t Serve Breakfast In Hell, or, It’s Good To Be Disc Jockey | What Now?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s